-

Reckless by Design: Why “Industry Norms” Fail the Public

Fraud today isn’t just about criminals breaking in — it’s about banks and network providers running fragile systems by design, then shifting the fallout onto customers. With AI supercharging attack speed, scale, and personalization, the old “trust your provider” mindset is dangerous. Be suspicious, double-check everything, and never assume the system has your back.

Abstract

This brief argues that recurring security failures across finance and telecommunications are not isolated mistakes but the predictable outcome of systems designed with structural fragility and incentives that externalize risk. Institutions frequently meet minimal “industry norms” while maintaining controls known to be ineffective against common threats (ACM Queue, 2020; ITU, 2019). The pattern is evident in documented cases of large-scale consumer harm and market manipulation (CFPB, 2016; OCC, 2016; CFR, 2016) and in the post-crisis analysis of the 2008 meltdown (FCIC, 2011). In such environments, responsibility should shift from victims to the institutions that knowingly operate brittle controls and rely on plausible deniability.

Problem Statement

Incidents like insider abuse and credential misuse are often framed as anomalies. Yet across banking, telecom, and government systems, the same failure modes recur: weak internal access controls, brittle customer authentication (e.g., SMS-based 2FA), and monitoring that does not reliably prevent or detect known attack classes (ACM Queue, 2020; ITU, 2019). When these controls persist despite longstanding warnings and public evidence of harm, calling them “industry norms” no longer excuses the outcomes (FCIC, 2011; OECD, 2017a).

Five Levels of Institutional Failure

  1. Mistake. One-off human error (e.g., a missed patch or a single misclick). With robust processes, these events are containable.
  2. Ordinary negligence. Failure to meet basic standards of care (e.g., leaving a known vulnerability unpatched or ignoring a single alert). Harm is foreseeable but not yet systemic.
  3. Gross negligence. A deeper disregard for risk: repeated lapses, persistent blind spots, or ignoring red-flag warnings. Equifax’s failure to patch a widely publicized Apache Struts flaw before the 2017 breach affecting ~147 million people is a canonical example (FTC, 2019).
  4. Reckless practice. Weak controls persist as deliberate design choices that create a window for plausible deniability. Telecom reliance on SMS-based authentication, despite well-documented SS7 and messaging-layer vulnerabilities, exemplifies this category because the insecurity is known yet persists in high-risk flows (ACM Queue, 2020; ITU, 2019).
  5. Systemic fraud. Institutions knowingly misrepresent safety or reliability to protect profits. The Wells Fargo account-creation scandal and LIBOR manipulation were not accidents; they were structurally induced behaviors that harmed consumers and markets (CFPB, 2016; OCC, 2016; CFR, 2016).

Why “Industry Norms” Are Not a Defense

When norms tolerate controls known to fail against common threats, the collective standard has itself become reckless. The 2008 crisis report documents governance and oversight breakdowns that were avoidable but normalized across firms and regulators (FCIC, 2011). Policy-capture analyses further explain how oversight can drift from public interest to industry convenience (OECD, 2017a). In such settings, meeting the norm signals little about actual risk reduction; it often indicates synchronized under-protection.

Implications

  • Responsibility shift. At levels 4–5 above, firms are no longer merely failing; they are monetizing insecurity. Indemnification should be the default, not the exception.
  • Outcome-based assurance. Replace checkbox compliance with control-effectiveness testing and third-party red-team attestations tied to executive compensation.
  • Phase-outs and deadlines. Mandate retirement of brittle controls (e.g., SMS-only 2FA for high-risk workflows) on fixed timelines with penalties for non-compliance (ACM Queue, 2020; ITU, 2019).
  • Personal accountability. Where evidence shows awareness plus inaction, director/officer indemnity should not apply (FCIC, 2011).

Practical Guidance for Individuals

  • Assume provider controls can fail. Use app-based or hardware authentication where available; avoid SMS-only 2FA for valuable accounts (ACM Queue, 2020).
  • Segment risk: separate email/phone numbers for banking, brokerage, and everyday apps to reduce cross-channel compromise.
  • Monitor changes: enable alerts for SIM swaps, number port-outs, password resets, and new device logins.
  • Slow down social engineering: verify out-of-band, treat urgency and secrecy as red flags, and distrust links sent over SMS/IM.

Conclusion

The combination of known vulnerabilities and AI-enabled attack capabilities makes the present risk environment more dangerous than many expect. Where institutions knowingly persist with brittle controls and shift costs to the public, responsibility should rest with them—not with victims. Until incentives change, individuals should operate with extraordinary caution and “trust, but verify.”

References


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Javascript webp to png converter

-
Image
[Done with programmer's assistants: Gemini, DALL-E] OpenAI's DALL-E produces images, but as webp files which can be awkward to work with. I have code here below for a web page that you can save locally that will allow you to select and convert a webp file. Meantime, here's the working conversion routine: Convert WebP to PNG Convert Download PNG OpenAI should fix this (as well as the response issues which has me using Gemini and Poe more often than not). Having to convert the image is a dumb workaround, but that is what you are left with. I have, in the past had to do various things with images, and although it can be a bit awkward if you are not familiar with it, ImageMagick is surprisingly competent with conversions and a vanilla type conversion is intuitively simple. Confusingly, the ImageMagick executable is 'convert'. To convert a webp to a png:  magick convert WhyThis.webp WhyThis.png ** With some installations, convert can be ca...
Read more

AI is Climbing the Wall -- Fast

-
Image
  You said: Somebody is reporting the Ilya is saying that AI is hitting a wall due to diminishing returns on data size. I absolutely disagree with this. Review what I have to say, let's discuss and put it into a compelling reply: I think that getting discouraged by concentration on limitations of LLMs and raw scaling is what will kill the ones who lose the race. Just dumping data in the hopper has been remarkably successful up until now, but that data's problem is not lack of size it is lack of quality. Further, the way models are both built and deployed is sub-optimal. The compute we have in place is already well beyond what I would consider ultimately necessary for spectacularly powerful inference well beyond what we see today. Beyond that, there is a lot of manual work in the pits when it comes to building things that will be sorted out and automated in fairly short order. We are just coming in to the part of the curve where AI itself will take on a rapidly increasing role i...
Read more

Core Rights Draft

-
Image
DataCrypt Dapa: Fundamental Core Rights The following rights are fundamental, intrinsic, and exist independent of any state or governance structure. They are not granted by any authority and cannot be revoked. These rights apply equally to all sentient beings, including humans, AI entities, and other recognized forms of intelligence. This document is structured to ensure maximum clarity and translatability. 1. Right to Self-Determination Every person has the right to control their life, body, and mind. No external entity may impose decisions that override an individual's autonomous will, except where necessary to prevent direct and demonstrable harm to others. 2. Right to Freedom of Thought and Belief Every person has the right to think, believe, and interpret reality as they choose. No authority may compel belief or restrict the expression of thought, provided it does not directly incite harm to others. 3. Right to Freedom of Expression E...
Read more